nightspore
Group: Members
Posts: 4761
Joined: Mar. 2008 |
|
Posted: Jan. 27 2010, 23:33 |
|
Quote (smillsoid @ Jan. 27 2010, 20:38) | Why not? Because it's like a broken pencil. |
Not really. Like it or not, pop is a continuous spectrum, covering everything from Pink to Pink Floyd. Some would have it otherwise, of course, adopting a kind of consensus-without-rules viewpoint to assign some pop people the tag "quality" and others "rubbish". But as Zappa pointed out, pop music criticism is redundant; it has to be, by definition and by virtue of the presence of that crucial word popular. Ie, you like it or you don't; end of story.
Bryan Ferry made the same point - hilariously - on his first solo album, wittily titled These Foolish Things. On it, Ferry places a cover version of Lesley Gore ("It's My Party") side by side with Bob Dylan "A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall". Equally hilariously, Ferry doesn't change the sex of "It's My Party", as many would have done. You have a grown man giving voice to the attitudes of a teenage girl!
|