Baggiesfaninessex
Group: Members
Posts: 682
Joined: Mar. 2002 |
|
Posted: May 07 2005, 07:01 |
|
Quote (familyjules @ April 12 2005, 08:53) | Quote (hiawatha @ April 12 2005, 08:28) | The analogy was weak, but as for "what happened 30 years ago", I think things would have been much better of prog had continued to flourish and punk had never happened. |
Ah well, I must respect your opinion, but as I've said before I was glad punk came along as by 1974/5/6 I think the rock music establishment had become self satisfied, dull and pampered.
And nobody of any stature lost their careers or fanbase.
Mind you, punk did seem to nudge Mike along the road to making 3 minute pop songs, something I have ambivalent feelings about.
Jules |
I think rock at the time was as diverse as it always has been. There was Glam, Heavy, Prog - it wasn't all the latter you know. Really, Prog never found a niche in the singles market - true prog never will - and I think it was more the media that lambasted prog's genius as pretentious and overblown, while the more discerning listener continued to crave far more than 3 minutes of 3 chords to which one could pogo, spit and generally cause mayhem.
Many say that Punk exploded onto the scene - maybe it exploded into the UK singles chart for a short while in the mid-70s - but Punk as a culture had been around since the 60s so explosion maybe overstating the case somewhat.
Thankfully Punk imploded very quickly - it never really was going to go anywhere in the music scene. There is only so much abuse that 3 chords and listeners can take. What came afterwards in the form of New Wave and New Romantics was the natural progression and the antithesis respectively following Punk's counter-cultural ideals.
Ironically, at the Canterbury Fayre in 2002, The Stanglers and The Damned shared the bill with Fish, ex members of King Crimson, The Ozric Tentacles, Kevin Ayres, Mostly Autumn, Arthur Brown, The Pretty Things, etc....aging Punks and Prog fans of all ages got along extremely well, standing shoulder to shoulder and watching 3 days and nights of fantastic music!
-------------- “A dog is not intelligent. Never trust an animal that's surprised by its own farts.” - Frank Skinner
|